
Sports Minister Gayton McKenzie has apologised to Olympic champion Tatjana Smith over her treatment by Swimming South Africa (SSA), while calling for a comprehensive investigation into the federation’s administration, finances and governance.
Speaking during a media briefing at Parliament on Tuesday, 17 November, McKenzie said he had lost confidence in Swimming SA and believed urgent intervention was needed following Smith’s decision to pursue her swimming career under the Dutch flag.
The minister said he had no hard feelings towards Smith for choosing to represent the Netherlands. Instead, he blamed the federation’s handling of her affairs, arguing that one of the country’s most successful swimmers had not received the respect she deserved.
“She’s been treated in the worst possible way. They should be ashamed,” McKenzie said.
He also accused Swimming SA of attempting to shift the blame onto Smith after news of her intended switch became public.
McKenzie highlights €46 000 dispute with Swimming SA
One of the major issues raised by McKenzie was Smith’s dispute with Swimming SA over prize money linked to her performances at the 2023 World Championships in Fukuoka, Japan.
According to the minister, Smith was issued a €46 000 penalty over an alleged sponsorship infringement after she failed to wear a particular sponsor’s brand.
The federation subsequently withheld her prize money, leading to a lengthy dispute. McKenzie said Smith only received the outstanding payment in 2024 after involving her lawyers.
He added that his department had ensured all money owed to the swimmer by the department was paid promptly.
“We paid her as fast as she swims. We want to thank her for the years that she’s given, for the medals that she’s given us, for what she’s done for this country,” he said.
McKenzie described Smith as South Africa’s greatest Olympian and insisted that she deserved an apology for the way she had been treated.
SASCOC given 90 days to investigate Swimming SA
McKenzie has formally approached the South African Sports Confederation and Olympic Committee (SASCOC), requesting a full investigation into Swimming SA’s operations.
The probe will examine the federation’s sponsorship agreement with Arena, including the penalties imposed on athletes, how those penalties were handled and who was expected to pay them.
Investigators will also be asked to establish whether other swimmers have faced similar fines or had their prize money withheld.
The investigation will extend to the federation’s financial and governance structures. McKenzie wants SASCOC to examine how funds were spent on the Franschhoek High-Performance Centre and identify possible shortcomings in Swimming SA’s constitution.
The minister believes Smith’s situation could point to wider problems within the federation rather than an isolated dispute.
“I’ve asked it to establish how the Arena sponsorship agreement works, what penalties were levied and who paid them, and whether other swimmers were fined or had money held back,” he said.
“I’ve asked it to look at how money was spent on the Franschhoek High-Performance Centre and the flaws in the federation’s constitution. And that’s why our swimmers are choosing to represent other countries.”
SASCOC acting head Lwandile Simelane has committed to completing the investigation within 90 days.
McKenzie explained that the regulations require SASCOC to address the matter first, making its investigation the initial step before any further action is considered.
McKenzie calls for urgent intervention at Swimming SA
Beyond the investigation, McKenzie wants SASCOC to establish a task team to help stabilise Swimming SA.
He expressed serious concern about the federation’s current state, arguing that its leadership and administration require urgent attention.
“I’ve asked SASCOC to deploy a task team to stabilise the federation, because the federation is in ICU. And we should not run away from that,” he said.
The minister also promised that Smith’s experience should not be repeated, warning national sporting federations against treating athletes in a similar manner.
“But I want to assure South Africans that she’s the last athlete who will be treated in such a fashion by these federations. That is not how a national federation should treat the people it exists to serve,” McKenzie said.
Tatjana Smith’s Netherlands decision puts Swimming SA under scrutiny
Smith’s decision to pursue representation by the Netherlands has sparked debate about athlete welfare, sponsorship obligations and the management of South African sporting bodies.
The swimmer won gold in the 200m breaststroke at the Tokyo 2020 Olympics before claiming silver in the same event at Paris 2024.
Her intended departure has now triggered renewed scrutiny of Swimming SA, with questions being raised about how athletes are treated and whether the federation’s internal structures are working in their interests.
McKenzie’s intervention has placed the federation’s sponsorship arrangements, financial management and governance firmly in the spotlight.
The findings of the 90-day SASCOC investigation could have important consequences for Swimming SA and the future of swimming in South Africa.
For now, the minister has made his position clear: Tatjana Smith deserved better, and he wants answers about the decisions and systems that contributed to her departure.















